10mm Vs 45 Acp Stopping Power

The difference is a function of the terminal performance of the bullets involved. 45 ACP has more recoil than a 9mm Luger. 357 McSilly or the 10mm isn't actually going to make a difference in terminal ballistic performance. So if you compare the actual 9mm vs 40 S&W vs 45 ACP “stopping power” (incapacitation) numbers, it boils down to a measly. In self-defense, power equates to penetration or over-penetration. Of course, you can step up to a hot 10mm that blows any 45 away. I have read all three stopping power books and I know the 9mm load is 91% effective, but Quick-Shok 10mm loads are not listed. the 9mm does not have the stopping power they want. When we’d go on family hikes, I’d be in front of the group with a. What has more stopping power out of a judge?. 45: Which Chambering Has More Stopping Power? Modern bullet technology has improved many calibers. In reality when I'm home I grab the shot gun with a revolver backup. Ask the pickup load of venison I've take over the years with. Ballistics wise, the 10mm wins over the. Its father was organizational ego, its mother posterior covering. 40 S&W and. 45 ACP full-metal-jacket. From what I've gathered, you have a chance to connect with the hips of an average grizzly with a frontal shot using heavy hard casts. 45 Colt, which also was for several decades. 45 ACP debate isn't so much about velocity and diameter as it is boring scientific data versus myth and legend. The 9mm has less stopping power than the. @1100fps or 185gr. 10mm pushes a hundred FPS or so more with 200 grain vs a 200 grain. For the latter, it gets a little tougher. about the same power factor. They all have a permanent wound cavity that is virtually indistinguishable from one round to the next. One look at that image shows that to be. Improvement typically relates to even more effective or desirable properties of bullet expansion: the "next generation" of hollow point handgun ammunition. Settling 9mm vs. The lower recoil will boost accuracy, but it won’t significantly decrease the stopping power of the round. 45 ACP, which. The 10mm would just penetrate even deeper than the. handgun stopping power. I beg to differ although the 10mm is faster I don't think it's got as much power as the. The naysayers also attack the reliability of the round saying that it is an unusually high pressure round. I own many different caliber handguns in order to experience their different characteristics. How about another argument - controllability. However, my weapon of choice would probably be a Springfield Arms 1911. No, the results are perfectly linear. 40 caliber has its own merits. 45 ACP 45 GAP 45 Colt 454 Casull 460. It is a low pressure cartridge that shoots heavy-bullets slowly, and. 45 acp due to the powder load/bullet mass ratio of the round. I bought a G29 for my CCW needs mostly because I used to carry a G32 and decided that I needed some added power of a hunting side arm for predator protection. com)-The 10mm but the 357’s overall longer bullet gives it the edge for penetrating power. The 45 ACP is my favorite defensive handgun cartridge and I have alot of experience with it. Glock Glock 10mm Vs 357 Magnum. We'd like to personally and specifically thank Pat Childs at Fin & Feather in Iowa City, as he not only helped get most of our ammunition and other supplies, he was the brilliant gunsmith who worked with us to make this insane project much more practical. Some gun owners want as much power as they can handle. An analysis of “. 45 ACP does at the muzzle. It fires rimless,. " Folks, carry what. Swampfox, Doubletap, and Buffalobore come to mind as 3 makers of full power 10mm that is equivalent to what the round was originally supposed to be. The funny thing about the 9mm is the number of people shot. I'll give you mine with a few facts to support my position, and you will have some foundation as to whether you have enough stopping power for your needs or not. 45 ACP became an effective round for combat and self defense. 45 ACP does at the muzzle. 45 ACP produces moderate recoil and as a result is easy to handle. 45 ACP is considered expensive then 10mm can be seen as costing a fortune on ammunition cost. 45 has a great rep for stopping power. As for "knockdown power", both 45 ACP and 10mm will do the job if you do yours. 45 ACP counters that it is bigger at 100 yards than the 10mm at the muzzle. Question about 45 acp stopping power? I carry a. Rep Power 8. , flatter trajectory, greater range) than the. I would say go 9mm glock 17, its what you are used to. Its father was organizational ego, its mother posterior covering. Both the full power 10mm and 460. I know comfort is important put I want to know if I will be safe with a. Arcane formulas combining bullet weight, velocity and diametre in various proportions are proposed, established, fretted over and adopted -- or discarded -- in search of a pistol/round combination that will "guarantee" that the user will emerge victorious in an armed confrontation. While the classic. (If my choice were between the. the US Marines still use the 1911 as their main side arm. 45 ACP Velocity : Testing A Modern Classics’ Power & Performance” This is the analysis for an experiment performed by Josh Wayner over at ammoland. 10mm at the Range. 45 ACP, while others find the light and slim nature of the 9mm to be more easy to use. 45 ACP for deer hunting - is the 10mm significantly better? We touched on this briefly in a previous discussion, but I thought I would go a little more in-depth. 45 ACP as far as stopping power and enjoyment to target shoot with them, any opinons would be great. 45 is sub sonic while the 9mm is super sonic. It’s a big reason why it was adopted alongside the 1911 for U. the 9mm does not have the stopping power they want. 45 probably has a slight edge on the 10mm in "stopping power," but the 10mm generally offers more rounds in a platform of similar size. The myth, the legend: the. 44 Special is the best handgun caliber Me that aren't as loud and the. Hydra-Shock is the best 45 ACP ammo for self defense for shooters that have trouble with heavy recoil. FBI and most typical 10mm vs. I've got a Colt Delta Elite. 44 Special is so much lower in "stopping power" than the. 10mm vs 45 ACP - YouTube. As far as power is concerned, there is, therefore, no outright winner in the discussion on 9mm vs. 357 McSilly or the 10mm isn’t actually going to make a difference in terminal ballistic performance. To your original question comparing the hard cast 10mm bullets to. Find rifles for sale at discount prices. My point here isn't that a. 45 out of the water as far as power is concerned. 40 or if I should go with. 40 ACP - the cartridge you're thinking is the. 38 caliber cartridges. The 10mm Auto provides a hand gunner with the power of a. Springfield Armory's most elite production 1911, now available in the potent 10mm cartridge. It fires rimless,. It's always a great match up that clearly defines the legendary stopping power of. , flatter trajectory, greater range) than the. Just carry a "deer" gun, and you will likely be covered, mouse to moose, as long as you stay current in your practice. ) Their failure to stop rates were all within 1%. On the 10mm side of the fence they like to point out that it has more energy at 100 yards vs the. These bullets are swaged and copper plated to their final wight, then they are re-struck to ensure each projectile is identical. 45 ACP? Discover the advantages and disadvantages of each caliber. 45 ACP's will spin you like a top. Most of us agree that "stopping power" is a hard to define subject. They say that if one wants to upgrade from 9mm to a larger caliber then one should choose 10mm. Don't see many of these, never shot one. However, muzzle energy is quantifiable, and 10mm has a significant increase of muzzle energy over. 40 - My point is for the ultimate round that has the best mix of stopping power, versus cost of ammunition and recoil its hard to beet the. Hydra-Shock is the best 45 ACP ammo for self defense for shooters that have trouble with heavy recoil. (If my choice were between the. The lower recoil will boost accuracy, but it won’t significantly decrease the stopping power of the round. Shooting both 10mm and. Power Factor is the product of the bullet weight in grains multiplied by the muzzle velocity in feet per second. Sellier & Bellot 10mm Auto 180 Grain FMJ. Glock Glock 10mm Subcompact Review. It was fired from a Dan Wesson Patriot. 45 ACP was specifically designed for the US Army to be a knock down round at short distances; intended to put a man down with just a couple of shots. 357 Sig or. My question is would I be better off with the 9mm loaded with Federal pble+p+, or the 10mm loaded with Triton Quick-Shock 165gr, 1300fps, 745ftlbs. Army was looking for a round to replace their. 10mm vs 40 Smith & Wesson. a average pellet of 00bk caries around 400ft lbs of energy and those rounds will tear apart. The large bullet makes for excellent one-shot stopping power. 45 out of the water as far as power is concerned. The 45 ACP loads I've seen (and I do have a 1911), are 350-500ft lbs. 45 LAW ENFORCEMENT USE. He wanted to design a pistol round that had more stopping power. 45 ACP? If so I. 38 Super, 10mm,. In the terms of raw, stopping power, the. 357 doesn't really matter and 10mm is probably too much because it can over-penetrate quite easily. Which has more stopping power 9mm or. 45 ACP at shorter ranges, with. 1911 owners, we are doing it damage to the shock buff when firing full power 10mm loads as occured in 45 acp with a stock firing pin stop and mainspring tension. Both the full power 10mm and 460. 45 caliber is the best, due to its stopping power. 9mm has better penetration. 10mm vs 45 ACP which has more stopping power. With this in mind, the FBI began to conduct ballistics testing to potentially find a new official sidearm caliber. you won't have any problems killing a whitetail at 75 yards with the 45 ACP. 357 Mag vs. 10mm auto, with proper defensive loads, is much more powerful than most. 45 ACP and generates a. And by "full power" I mean the 10mm Auto loads loaded to 37,500psi. 45 probably has a slight edge on the 10mm in "stopping power," but the 10mm generally offers more rounds in a platform of similar size. Thehighroad. There's actually three 45 autos: 45 ACP, which is the most common and generally what everyone means when they refer to a 45 auto 45 Autorim, much less common and the exact same as a 45 ACP with an added rim for revolvers 45 GAP, Glock Auto Pistol. 45 Colt, which also was for several decades. The American forces needed something with more stopping power than their standard issue, and Colt answered the call. I have one 10mm for occasional town carry and for woods carry. 40 S&W and the 9 mm Parabellum both operate at a 35,000 psi (240 MPa) SAAMI maximum, compared to a 21,000 psi (150 MPa) maximum for. In the terms of raw, stopping power, the. ’” Sometimes you’ll hear, “The 9mm and. 357sig remains one of my favorites for real world defense. The Iconic Colt Delta Elite Offers 10mm to 1911 Fans. 16mm) diameter bullets. FBI and most typical 10mm vs. , flatter trajectory, greater range) than the. 44 Special so low in "stopping power" vs. 10mm vs 45 +P. If you choose to use a lighter load then don’t expect the same performance from the round. Today on Kentucky Ballistics we shoot some 10% ballistic gel with 10mm and 45 ACP + P. People on the other side have claimed that the. Just carry a "deer" gun, and you will likely be covered, mouse to moose, as long as you stay current in your practice. vs the lighter 180 gr. A couple of weeks ago I found an article that correctly calculated the frontal diameter of. 45 ACP load is a 230-grain bullet fired at 830 fps for about 355 foot-pounds of muzzle energy. The bottom line is they wanted a effective fighting weapon and cartage and I think that is what they chose. 40 or if I should go with. Glock Glock 10mm Vs 357 Magnum. One of the advantages the. 45 ACP simply because I've always liked it & wouldn't mind owning one; & that's the ONLY reason, not because I think it's a superior "Survival" round. 45 it's a hard hitting slug and the fact it moves slower means its got more stopping power in my opinion their both great guns but for the biggest and baddest G21 Gen 4 is my pick. 45 ACP and the 10mm. 41mag, but if I had to choose. This article has helped me understand the differences between the 45 ACP and the 10 mm. In short, I've been quite satisfied with Hornady's XTP bullet and suggest giving it a try, either as loaded ammunition or as a component if you reload. 40 S&W, or the. entirely biased. 357 Sig or. Josh was kind enough to share both his data and provide input in the analysis below. This is a discussion on 45acp/10mm within the Defensive Ammunition & Ballistics forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; Hi I would like to get all of your thoughts and opinions. Army was looking for a round to replace their. The 45 has more attributes that I personally care for, low cost practice ammo, a few dB lower noise level, more commonly found on shelves, and seems to be about the same as what people are killing deer with in a 300bo subsonic, so I cannot convince myself to buy another 10. 5mm) so it is slightly larger than the 9mm (. "40 years of Experience" 3 or 4 expanded 9mms will do about what a. Cheaper Than Dirt! has the ammo in stock to feed your. I have a 10mm and like it. The cartridge comes in four main variants namely, the. It seems obvious that a bullet that strikes a hand, leg, arm or foot, will almost certainly never bring about instantaneous incapacitation. Top; All;. 45 has better stopping power IMO. 45 back to back can make the 10mm seem like quite the barn-burner, but consistent practice with full-power loads will acquaint you with the recoil and you won't notice it. No, the results are perfectly linear. 45 ACP's will spin you like a top. I don't think the 10mm Auto is death ray, even though it was 2/2. 109 Responses to Marine Operators Have Settled the 9mm vs. Lot of good info here and all. I believe Buffalo Bore loads some full house 10mm loads. I think that a 45 +P with high performance ammo (Cor-bon DPX, TAP, etc. 45 ACP became an effective round for combat and self defense. 45 with more foot-lbs energy using comparable bullets. It flies at a higher velocity than. Like I said Im not stating the 10mm is equal to a. com)- A while back (2014) the FBI published a long diatribe defending their decision to go to the 9mm round as their. 410 hollow point slug. The bottom line is they wanted a effective fighting weapon and cartage and I think that is what they chose. 85" travels around 1074 fps from a 6" barrel and has an average 423 foots pounds per square inch. And yes I know you said one shot only but I'll add that if this is any type of life taking/protecting incident outside of hunting I'd prefer a semi auto and traditionaly the. Have heard stories both about. 45 ACP handguns for protection. 9 mm technology vs. 45: The Definitive Article On Caliber Performance. They all have a permanent wound cavity that is virtually indistinguishable from one round to the next. stopping power is a bs term. So popular, it could wear the title "America's Cartridge. The 9mm, the. 45 ACP is your best option. It is, however, worth noting that the choice of a handgun to buy depends on the buyer's personal decisions. 45: The 10mm will blow that. 45 Still, A. 45 acp A younger friend of mine today told me that. 44 Magnum, and. 44 Magnum,. Don't see many of these, never shot one. The FBI protocol calls for more penetration, and therefore less expansion, than is desirable to maximize stopping power in most shooting situations. In self-defense, power equates to penetration or over-penetration. What do you shoot best? That is the best round. 45 is really inconsequential. 45 ACP was specifically designed for the US Army to be a knock down round at short distances; intended to put a man down with just a couple of shots. Just carry a "deer" gun, and you will likely be covered, mouse to moose, as long as you stay current in your practice. 45 regularly is considered to have more stopping power than a 9. The large-bore fan might proclaim, "Take a 147-grain 9mm bullet that might be going 950 to 980 fps from a compact pistol, and a 180-grain. Nov 19, 2014 · Simple little video to see if I can tell the difference in felt recoil between the. 30 Carbine round is not a full-power rifle round, but then again, neither is. Perhaps to be able to occasionally experience the power of 10 mm. The “grin per shot” factor is very high at the range. I have always thought bigger caliber better stopping power. As far as the. , flatter trajectory, greater range) than the. 5mm) If you just want to know which one is better, and no other information is given, the answer is. 357sig remains one of my favorites for real world defense. 45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol) uses bullets with diameters of. The 10mm auto cartridge with a height of 0. 45 out of the water as far as power is concerned. 40 S&W combine high-capacity magazines with acceptable stopping power. 45 ACP +P Buffalo Bore 255-grain Hard Cast FN. 357 Sig is a great round ,it goes cleanly through auto glass and Auto body metal and retains its stopping power on those unlucky enough to be shot with it. The cartridge comes in four main variants namely, the. Who Wins Out In 10mm vs. It is one of the cartridges that have a great history. 357 magnum is the best experience you can have with a handgun — as noted in an earlier post, a Sig is like a fine watch. The defensive potential and pedigree is all there. 45 Colt ballistically, but not quite as powerful. 40 S&W and the 9 mm Parabellum both operate at a 35,000 psi (240 MPa) SAAMI maximum, compared to a 21,000 psi (150 MPa) maximum for. With regards to stopping power, imo, that is like saying what is the best car? Best for what? Define your stopping power. 45 caliber is the best, due to its stopping power. For everyone else:. In my opinion, the Army Aviators story about the stopping power of a. , flatter trajectory, greater range) than the. Well, I've been wavering between a. Full house 10mm vs. you won't have any problems killing a whitetail at 75 yards with the 45 ACP. There we said it and the FBI agrees. The gun rags of the era were filled with “9mm vs. I have used the full power stuff to take several large wild hogs and one small. Glock Glock 10mm Subcompact Review. Sellier & Bellot 10mm Auto 180 Grain FMJ. 45 ACP works well in semi-automatic pistols, and its large diameter creates greater wound channels. Shooting the 45ACP and 10mm. 40 S&W was developed specifically for law enforcement needs. Some of these cartridges were actually designed for use in rifles, but many handguns in our database have variants that are chambered for rifle cartridges. I have used the full power stuff to take several large wild hogs and one small. I also own two 10mm pistols. 45 ACP 45 GAP 45 Colt 454 Casull 460. With good bullet design I'd be more confident with a 110 gr. We are always working to originate the next technological innovation and we thoroughly enjoy what we do. 45 totals combined. 45 ACP does at the muzzle. , flatter trajectory, greater range) than the. 10mm pushes a hundred FPS or so more with 200 grain vs a 200 grain. 45 ACP round at 900 FPS. Winchester Ranger 45 ACP AUTO 230 Grain +P T-Series Bonded Jacketed Hollow Point ammo review offers the following information; Winchester Ranger 45 ACP Auto ammo for sale that features a 230 Grain Bonded Jacketed Hollow Point T-Series bullet. 357 Magnum revolver with the increased magazine capacity and rapid reload capability of an automatic pistol. 38 caliber cartridges. I have seen a. This particular cartridge was designed for the popular 1911 pistol. 45 is definitely more controllable than a 10mm, ending the argument 10mm vs. 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) cartridge you're looking at purchasing. 45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol) cartridge holds bullets that have a diameter of. 45 ACP load is a 230-grain bullet fired at 830 fps for about 355 foot-pounds of muzzle energy. 45 ACP and capable of greater stopping power than the 9×19mm Parabellum. And by "full power" I mean the 10mm Auto loads loaded to 37,500psi. The 9mm has less stopping power than the. 45 ACP and generates a. Which has the most stopping power?. More commonly referred to as just 10mm or 10x25mm, the 10mm Auto was first chosen for use by the FBI in 1989 after the aftermath of the 1986 Miami shootout. ’” Sometimes you’ll hear, “The 9mm and. The defensive potential and pedigree is all there. Corbon has a 10mm load that appears to be identical. 45 probably has a slight edge on the 10mm in "stopping power," but the 10mm generally offers more rounds in a platform of similar size. , flatter trajectory, greater range) than the. Shooting the 10mm is an intense experience, like shooting a Magnum revolver. 85" travels around 1074 fps from a 6" barrel and has an average 423 foots pounds per square inch. 45 ACP that gives the hands a strong but smooth shove, the 10mm gives you all its recoil at once, in a sharper, more insistent slap against the hands. Others think 9mm trumps all or the. It's a big reason why it was adopted alongside the 1911 for U. the 10 mm does kick allitle harder than the. 45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol) cartridge holds bullets that have a diameter of. 357 Sig has plenty of. The gun rags of the era were filled with “9mm vs. Stopping power can be expected to be about the same, though every shooting is an individual event. If you choose to use a lighter load then don't expect the same performance from the round. 452 inches (11. On then street I carry a revolver (357 mag) primary and a pistol (9mm) backup. Gun Review: Sig Sauer's P220 Match Elite 10mm Handgun The front end of the frame has three rail sections that allow for the attachment of accessories such as a light or a laser. 45 ACP? Discover the advantages and disadvantages of each caliber. Every big PD in America was switching from wheelguns to Berettas and 3rd Gen S&W pistols. 45 back to back can make the 10mm seem like quite the barn-burner, but consistent practice with full-power loads will acquaint you with the recoil and you won't notice it. the US Marines still use the 1911 as their main side arm. 45 acp A younger friend of mine today told me that. com)-The 10mm but the 357's overall longer bullet gives it the edge for penetrating power. The FBI had its magic bullet. Calibers listed are all good calibers. "Stopping power" isn't an actual metric. Right now, the battle seems to be between a Springfield XD45, and a 10mm 1911. It recoils less and can be fired much more rapidly than the hard kicking 10mm. These bullets are swaged and copper plated to their final wight, then they are re-struck to ensure each projectile is identical. 45 has his tighty-whities in a wad, let me say this… It's NOT that a. 45 probably has a slight edge on the 10mm in "stopping power," but the 10mm generally offers more rounds in a platform of similar size. due to the round being faster, it may impart more energy on some rounds (like hollow point, which the US Gov has started to use recently, still takes multiple shots to take down an insurgent) vs a 45 ACP (which is slower, and bigger. I have one 10mm for occasional town carry and for woods carry. 45 caliber is the best, due to its stopping power. Since its origin, it has been used by the US military and has seen several wars, primarily being used in the Thompson submachine gun. 40 or if I should go with. In the late 19th century, the U. 44 Magnum, and. For the latter, it gets a little tougher. 40 - My point is for the ultimate round that has the best mix of stopping power, versus cost of ammunition and recoil its hard to beet the. 45: The 10mm will blow that. This is a discussion on 45acp/10mm within the Defensive Ammunition & Ballistics forums, part of the Defensive Carry Discussions category; Hi I would like to get all of your thoughts and opinions. 10mm vs 45 ACP - YouTube. 45 Colt carbines and handguns.